Ciao Italianista contains affiliate links and is a member of the Amazon Services LLS Associates Program. If you make a purchase using one of these Amazon links, I may receive compensation at no extra charge to you. See my disclosure policy for more information.
Renting Automatic Cars In Italy: What To Know
So you’re thinking about renting a car in Italy—bravo! You’re about to unlock medieval hill towns, lakefront drives, and villages so small they don’t even have a bus stop.
But here’s the catch: most of the cars on those twisty Italian roads are manual transmission. If driving a stick shift in the old country is #1 on your never want to do list, you might be wondering if renting automatic cars in Italy is even a thing.
When I posted this reel on Instagram of me panicking at the tollbooth, it blew up. Along with the video, I shared my top 10 things I learned while driving as an American in Italy in the caption. One of those tips was about how surprisingly hard it is to drive slowly in an automatic car.
That caught someone’s attention, and they asked me: “How is it hard to stay within the speed limit in an automatic car? Curious because I don’t understand.” Well, buckle up—I’m going to answer that (and a lot more) in this post.
Between speed limits that change faster than you can say mamma mia and cars that beep the second you’re 3 kph over, renting an automatic in Italy comes with quirks (and costs) you’ll definitely want to know about before you book.
👉 Need an automatic car in Italy? Auto Europe makes it easy to filter, compare, and book.
How Common Are Automatic Cars in Italy?
You’ll often hear people say that automatic cars are “almost non-existent” in Italy. As an experienced car renter in Italy, I can tell you—that’s simply not true.
Like everything else in Italy from the rise of supermarkets to the changing demographics, things are changing.
Rental agencies know their customers (aka tourists) want automatics, and they’ve adjusted. These days, you’ll find plenty of automatic transmission cars available at the big international companies and in major cities.
👉 Cultural Note: Why Manual Transmission Cars Still Rule in Italy
For decades, manuals weren’t just the default in Italy—they were practically the only option. Italians love cars and driving, and for many, the connection you feel with a manual transmission is part of the joy. Manuals are cheaper to buy, easier to maintain, and give drivers more control on Italy’s winding mountain roads and stop-and-go village streets. Automatic transmission may be gaining ground, but for locals, stick shifts are still the gold standard.
That said, manuals are still the majority. Automatics are out there, but they’re fewer in number and tend to get scooped up quickly. If you’ve got your heart set on one, you’ll definitely want to book well in advance—which brings us to the next point.
Booking an Automatic Car: Timing Is Everything
If you want an automatic car in Italy, timing is everything. The sweet spot is to reserve months in advance—but not a full year out. If you book too early, the rates can actually be higher. Prices tend to settle closer to your trip, so aim for a few months before departure.
Big companies like Hertz, Avis, or Sixt—and comparison sites such as Auto Europe—give you the best chance at finding an automatic. Smaller local agencies are far less likely to have them, and if they do, their stock is limited.
Here’s the catch: even when your reservation says “automatic confirmed,” that doesn’t mean you’re guaranteed the exact car you booked. I reserved an automatic Toyota Yaris and ended up with an Opel Corsa – which I had never heard of but ended up loving.
👉 Automatics sell out quick in Italy! Book early with Auto Europe to lock one in.
Pro Tip: Don’t Be Late for Pickup
Rental agencies in Italy don’t hold cars the way you might expect. If you’re more than an hour or two past your stated pickup time, your automatic could be handed off to someone else—especially in peak season. Always give yourself extra time to get through the airport or train station and head straight to the rental desk.
😅 My Experience: The Airport Bus Fiasco
We decided to pick up our rental car later in the trip, so we headed to the bus station to catch the airport shuttle. However…We had no idea where the bus actually left from—or how to buy a ticket. While we were still standing in line at the info desk, I spotted the bus pulling up in a totally different spot. We bolted, hopped on without tickets, and hoped for the best.
Two weeks later, when we returned the car, we had to take the same bus back. This time the driver wouldn’t even let us board without tickets—and we learned the fine for riding without one is hefty. Let’s just say we were very relieved nothing happened the first time.
The Price Difference
Here’s the not-so-fun part: renting an automatic car in Italy almost always costs more than renting a manual. In fact, the price difference can be steep—often 50% more for the same size car.
That means while your friend smugly rents a manual for $300 a week, you could be paying closer to $600 a week for a small automatic with full coverage.
And don’t forget about hidden fees. Some companies tack on surcharges for one-way rentals, picking up at airports, or dropping off outside of business hours. Always double-check what’s included in your rate and what’s not.
It’s easy for the “cheap” deal you clicked online to balloon once you’re standing at the counter with a pen in hand.
If you’ve got room in your budget, the peace of mind of driving an automatic may be worth it. But go in prepared so you’re not caught off guard by the sticker shock.
💶 Money Matters: Manual vs. Automatic
- Manuals are the budget option — often half the price of an automatic.
- Expect to pay around $600/week for a small automatic with full coverage.
- Watch for hidden fees: one-way rentals, airport pickup, and out-of-hours drop-offs can add up fast.
- Bottom line: manuals save money, automatics save stress.
Should You Learn (or Re-Learn) Manual Just for Italy?
It’s a fair question: if manuals are cheaper and more common, should you take a crash course in stick shift before your trip?
Some travelers recommend it—especially if they’ve got a year to practice and access to a manual car at home. With enough time behind the wheel, you could save money and feel confident driving like a local.
But for most people, the stress just isn’t worth it. Trust me. You don’t want to be in a busy Italian roundabout, traffic whizzing past, and you stall out. Now you’ve got a line of impatient drivers honking behind you while you fumble with the clutch. Things happen fast on Italian roads, and the coordination of clutch + gear shift + situational awareness can be overwhelming if you’re not already comfortable.
Unless you’re truly committed to practicing well in advance, you’re better off reserving an automatic and budgeting for the extra cost. You’ll thank yourself when you’re cruising Lake Garda instead of panicking in second gear.
Driving Challenges in an Automatic
Driving in Italy was one of my biggest worries before the trip—so much so that before I went, I wrote about overcoming my fear of driving a rental in Italy. And sure enough, the first panic attack came at the tollbooth.
When that tollbooth panic reel took off, people had a lot of questions. I want to answer this one: “Why is it so hard to stay within the speed limit in an automatic car?” It’s a fair question—but anyone who’s actually driven in Italy knows the struggle is real. If you haven’t seen it yet, you can catch the reel here.
Why Italian speed limits make automatics tricky
On provincial roads, the speed limit changes constantly. You’ll go from 90 kph to 50 kph to 30 kph, then back up to 70—all within a couple of kilometers. In a manual, you can downshift and use the gears to control your speed.
In an automatic, the car wants to keep rolling forward, so the only way to stay at 30 kph is to ride the brake… and trust me, 30 feels really slow when everyone is piling up behind you.
Constant braking vs. engine braking
That’s the big difference: manuals give you engine braking—you ease off the gas, drop a gear, and the car naturally slows down. With an automatic, it’s brake, brake, brake. Not only does this feel jerky, but after a few hours of navigating through small towns, your right foot is basically begging for a gelato break.
The dreaded speed-limit beeping system
And then there’s the cherry on top: many Italian rental cars come with a built-in system that beeps every time you creep more than 3 kph over the posted limit. Sounds helpful, right? In reality, it’s maddening.
After a week of nonstop beep-beep-beep, we finally figured out how to turn it off—only to discover it resets every time you restart the car.
😅 My Experience: The 30 kph Crawl
Everywhere I drove in Italy, I saw signs that said “Controllo elettronico della velocità.” By law, those signs have to appear before any fixed speed camera. Naturally, I thought every single one meant a camera was about to catch me in the act. I’d already heard the horror stories—tourists getting speeding tickets mailed to them months or even years later.
So there I was, in my automatic rental, doing my best to obey every sudden speed-limit change. Holding the car at 30 kph felt unnatural, and with an automatic that meant constant braking. Add in the car’s warning beep every time I nudged a few kilometers over, and driving through small towns turned into a nerve-wracking crawl.
Later, Italians told me that while the signs are everywhere, the actual cameras are rare—and even when they’re there, they don’t always work. Of course, I didn’t know that at the time. So I was hyper-vigilant, braking like crazy, convinced a ticket was lurking around every corner.
Blending In (or Not)
Even if you’re in an automatic, it won’t take Italians long to spot you as a foreign driver. Locals overwhelmingly use manuals, and their driving style is smooth and efficient—downshifting through roundabouts, accelerating confidently onto highways, and rarely touching the brakes unless absolutely necessary.
In an automatic, your driving pattern looks different. Constant braking at slow speeds, hesitation at gear changes you don’t control, and the occasional over-cautious crawl through a small town make it pretty obvious you’re not from around here. That’s not a bad thing—plenty of tourists do it—but don’t be surprised if the locals behind you grow impatient. Italians are quick with the horn, and in their eyes, driving is as much about rhythm and confidence as it is about following the rules.
If you can keep calm, ignore a little honking, and remember that you’re a guest on their roads, you’ll do just fine.
Is an Automatic Car Right for You?
So, should you pay extra for an automatic in Italy—or brave the stick shift? The answer depends on you.
If you’re already comfortable driving a manual, then renting one makes sense. You’ll save a chunk of money, blend in more easily with locals, and have the added control of engine braking on those winding provincial roads.
But if you’re not confident with a manual, the stress isn’t worth it. Stalling in a roundabout, fumbling for reverse, or hesitating at a green light while scooters buzz around you can turn a dream trip into a sweaty nightmare. In that case, an automatic is the smarter choice—even if it costs more.
The checklist before you book:
- Reserve early (months, not weeks, ahead).
- Book with a big rental company in a major city or airport.
- Double-check what’s included in your rate (coverage, fees, mileage).
- Show up on time for pickup—especially in peak season.
At the end of the day, the right choice is the one that keeps you focused on enjoying Italy, not stressing about gears.
➡️ Ready to book your automatic rental? Compare options here: Auto Europe
🚗 Read Next: Overcoming Fear of Driving a Rental Car in Italy
Before this trip, I had serious doubts about whether I could handle driving in Italy at all. In this post, I share the nerves, the what-ifs, and great information to know before you get behind the wheel. Spoiler alert: I am glad I rented a car. Read it here →
Planning your full Italian itinerary? Read More Of My Italy Travel Tips and Stories:
- The Best Way To Rent A Car In Italy — From Someone Who’s Done It
- Is It Hard To Drive In Italy? What Americans Need To Know
- Renting Automatic Cars in Italy: What to Know
- Overcoming Fear of Driving a Rental Car in Italy
- What I’m Packing For A Month In Italy On My Ancestry Trip
- Ancestry Tours In Italy: What To Expect
